http://www.citylab.com/housing/2015/07/berlins-brand-new-rent-control-laws-are-already-working/398087/
Enjoy the write up. :)
----------------------------------------------
Part
1: Summary of Article
The article
chosen mainly speaks about how rental price brake (mietpreisbremse) being
radical tool for keeping rent cost effective. Berlin’s
new rent control laws are already bringing down costs. In other German cities
where these laws are not relevant rents have remained more or less static. This
is good news for the legislators of Berlin’s Senate as their new law given the
public what they want. An overseeing body fixes a standard median rent per square
meter for each city district, using figures based a biennial state census of
rents. This means that price increases
for new rentals are possible but not in the near future. This
began at inner districts like Kreuzberg, currently the site of a passionate,
surprisingly high profile fight to save a local grocery store. To rectify this,
Berlin has introduced other laws planned to stop real estate hotspots from
overheating. Also, worries that lease control will
bring about the supply of condo to decrease have been halfway mollified by a
far reaching building program that ought to convey 30,000 new rental lofts
throughout the following decade. But the fact that Berlin’s combination of
tenants’ rights, rent brakes, and large-scale apartment building already shows
tentative signs of being effective is still persuasive. It’s perhaps a little naïve to see the rent control
laws as simply a triumph of the rights of the public. (O’Sullivan, 2015)
Part 2&3: Concepts and Graphs
The first concept I would like to acquaint with the article is market equilibrium; demand and supply.
The first concept I would like to acquaint with the article is market equilibrium; demand and supply.
Referring to the article, demand for an economist refers to willingness and
ability to pay the amount of rent set by the land lord. (Anon, 2015) Quantity demanded, Qd, is the total
amount of apartment a tenant is willing to rent for a price. Qd is usually effected by various conditions. (Anon, 2015) In this case, the condition would be the amount of rent for an
apartment based on the new rent control law in Berlin. (O’ Sullivan, 2015) The law of demand, based on the article, states that the new rent
control law ensures a lower rent price for all and this will lead to an
increase in quantity of apartment wanted for rent. Demand curve for this
situation will represent the rent prices and quantity of apartment demanded. (Anon, 2015)
When
it comes to supply, it refers to the relationship between price and quantity
supplied while everything else remains constant. (Hubbard and O'Brien, 2015) The quantity supplied, Qs, is the amount
of rent the land lord can choose to imply on the tenant and it effected by only
one condition being the price of input. (Anon, 2015) The law of supply based on the article, when
the rent prices decreases due to the rent control, the quantity supplied also
decreases. (O’ Sullivan,
2015) The supply curve will show the relationship between the price and
quantity supplied. (Hubbard and O'Brien, 2015)
When
both the demand and supply is placed together, an equilibrium when the supply
and demand cross can be found. The
equilibrium will satisfy the market clearing condition, Qd=Qs (Hubbard and O'Brien, 2015) This is all before
the price ceiling is set by the government through rent control.
The
rightward shift in supply which is caused by the lower price factor will lead
to two effects. The effects being the raise in equilibrium quantity and
reducing the equilibrium price as shown in the graph above. (Anon, 2015)
The second concept that can conceive from the article is price ceiling.
Based on the article, the rental price has decreases by 3.1% within a month and due to the new law, no new rental contract is allowed to charge over 10% more than this amount. (O’ Sullivan, 2015)
Based on the article, the rental price has decreases by 3.1% within a month and due to the new law, no new rental contract is allowed to charge over 10% more than this amount. (O’ Sullivan, 2015)
Rent control is a law setting a maximum price also called
rent ceiling based on what the land lord decide to charge the tenant. (Econlib.org,
2015)
Due to the rent control on
apartments and condos in Berlin, what can we actually predict to occur? A
shortage. (O’ Sullivan, 2015) A shortage is a situation in which the quantity
demanded is greater than the quantity supplied. (Hubbard and O'Brien, 2015) Buyers of
apartments cannot increase the price by propositioning each other because of
the law, price cannot be increased. On the flip side, this will decrease the
amount of apartments made available to the public. (Econlib.org, 2015)
This shortage will also lead a black market
which is a market where buying and selling occurs against government regulation
and laws. This market will ease the deadweight loss by providing more
apartments to be rented but with the cost of losing legal assurances. (Econlib.org,
2015)
Based on the
graph above, A is referring to the Producers Surplus which shows the price
transferred from the land lords to the tenants. While B and C are the areas
showing Dead Weight Loss which is parallel to the surplus that is from the
apartments that are no longer rented by any tenants. (Hubbard and O'Brien, 2015) It prevents mutually
beneficial trades from occurring. (Anon, 2015)
The third and final concept that can be derived from the article is, elasticity of demand and supply.
Elasticity of demand is defined as the responsiveness of the quantity demanded to a change in price. (Hubbard and O'Brien, 2015) Due to the rent ceiling causing lower rent prices, the tenants are fighting against each other to get the best apartments possible while the land lords just wait to collect their money. (Preservearticles.com, 2015) Tenants are price sensitive and this is due to various conditions such as proportion of income spent. The interest for those products on which an insignificant measure of the aggregate pay of the tenant is spent is said to be inelastic. Next is price level. The demand for high priced accommodation is elastic. In this case, due to the rent control, the apartments are said to have an inelastic demand due to their low price, it becomes a necessity. Last but not the least is income level. Both the rich and the poor are not necessary effected by the price change. The poorer people feels greater impact that the rich. (Preservearticles.com, 2015) Overall the elasticity of demand is elastic as the tenants are very responsive to the change in price. (Anon, 2015)
Elasticity of supply refers to the responsiveness of the quantity
supplied to the change in price. (Hubbard and O'Brien, 2015) Suppliers
make a benefit by offering merchandise and administrations at higher costs than
their expense to deliver. In this case, the landlords will be at a lost due to
the rent ceiling will make it difficult for them to make profits. (Econlib.org,
2015) Thus, the lower prices of rent, the landlords will react by
decreasing their supply which as mentioned above, will cause a shortage. The
elasticity of supply will be also be effected by the period of the law
implemented. (O’ Sullivan, 2015) Based
on this article, the change of supply is huge parallel to the drop in price,
making it elastic. Overall the elasticity of supply is very elastic as the
landlords are very responsive to the change in price of rent. (Anon, 2015)
Conclusion
The conclusion based on the points made above is that, based on the
market equilibrium of demand and supply, demand for an economist refers to
willingness and ability to pay the amount of rent set by the land lord. This is
all before the price ceiling is set by the government through rent control. In
this case, the condition would be the amount of rent for an apartment based on
the new rent control law in Berlin. The law of demand, based on the article,
states that the new rent control law ensures a lower rent price for all and
this will lead to an increase in quantity of apartment wanted for rent. The law
of supply based on the article, when the rent prices decreases due to the rent
control, the quantity supplied also decreases.
The second concept spoke about price ceiling. Rent control being a law
setting a maximum price also called rent ceiling based on what the land lord decide
to charge the tenant. Buyers of apartments cannot increase the price by
propositioning each other because of the law, price cannot be increased. Based
on the article, the rental price has decreases by 3.1% within a month and due
to the new law, no new rental contract is allowed to charge over 10% more than
this amount. The article has also stated that the shortage problem can be
partly gratified by the plan that there is a city-wide building program that
ensures 30,000 new rental apartments that will be available by the next decade.
The elasticity of both demand and supply is also proven to be very
elastic. This is because the change in price that has come about due to the new
rent control laws has effected both the tenant and the landlords greatly
together with the conditions stated above.
Based on the write up, I believe that this new law of rent control will
bring goodness to both the landlords and the tenants in a long run. The
decrease in cost will definitely be a big plus to those who are in terrible
need of shelters. This law will prove to be strong and durable in Germany. I
personally believe that this law should be implemented all over the world and
not just in Germany as this can definitely bring down the rate of homeless
people and more. Written this write up has definitely widen my horizons in the
economic point of view as well.
References
Anon, (2015). [online] Available at: http://www.csun.edu/~dgw61315/PTlect2y.pdf [Accessed 19 Oct.
2015].
Econlib.org, (2015). Rent Control:
The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics | Library of Economics and Liberty.
[online] Available at: http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentControl.html [Accessed 20 Oct.
2015].
Hubbard, R. and O'Brien, A. (2015).
Economics. Harlow: Pearson.
O' Sullivan, F. (2015). Berlin's
Brand New Rent Control Laws Are Already Working. [online] CityLab. Available
at: http://www.citylab.com/housing/2015/07/berlins-brand-new-rent-control-laws-are-already-working/398087/ [Accessed 19 Oct.
2015].
Preservearticles.com, (2015). 9
factors that determines the elasticity of demand. [online] Available at: http://www.preservearticles.com/201105307213/9-factors-that-determines-the-elasticity-of-demand.html [Accessed 25 Oct.
2015].
Spaulding, W. (2015). Supply
Elasticity. [online] Thismatter.com. Available at: http://thismatter.com/economics/supply-elasticity.htm [Accessed 25 Oct.
2015].
Thank you for reading. :)
Thank you for reading. :)

